Facebook noscript
Close Auto Insurance Leads | 5 Tips

5 Unbeatable Tips for Closing Aged Auto Insurance Leads

Every insurance agent understands the importance of timing in sales. Consider the effectiveness of older auto insurance leads – when handled well, they can lead to impressive outcomes like closing deals successfully.

At The Leads Warehouse, we understand the true value of aged auto insurance leads and how they can significantly boost your sales pipeline. Our comprehensive guide gives you five actionable strategies to close these leads effectively. Remember, the most delicious fruits are often those allowed to ripen.

1. Recognize the Value in Aged Leads

Aged leads are essentially potential customers who expressed interest in an insurance quote at some point but didn’t follow through with a purchase. While they may seem less appealing than real-time leads, they offer a unique advantage. Aged auto insurance leads are often less competitive, meaning you may have a larger pool to tap into.

Source:  Investopedia’s Guide on Insurance Leads

2. Optimize Your Customer Service Skills and Close more Auto Insurance Leads

Exceptional customer service can make or break a deal. Be friendly, approachable, and always aim to help. Patience is crucial, as you’ll likely be dealing with leads who’ve heard the same sales pitch from different insurance companies. Make sure to personalize your communication, noting details like the potential customer’s name and date of birth.

Source: Forbes Article on Customer Service Skills

3. Utilize Different Communication Channels

Don’t limit yourself to just phone numbers or email addresses. Today’s customers are on a variety of platforms, from social media to various online forums. Go where your leads are, and engage them on their preferred platform.

Source: HBR’s Guide on Multi-Channel Marketing

4. Understand the Type of Insurance Needed 

The more you know about what the lead is looking for, the better you can tailor your offer. Ask about their specific needs and concerns, whether it’s auto insurance, life insurance, or another type of coverage.

Source: NAIC’s Consumer Guide on Types of Insurance

5. Track Your ROI and Close Auto Insurance Leads

Tracking your return on investment (ROI) is essential to understand the cost and benefit of purchasing aged leads. If you find aged leads are providing a higher ROI than real-time leads, it may be worth allocating more resources toward aged lead generation.

Authoritative source: Inc.’s Guide on Tracking ROI


How much do aged leads cost? The cost of aged leads varies by the lead store or provider, with prices generally significantly lower than real-time leads due to their age.

What are aged leads? Aged leads are potential customers who expressed interest in a product or service in the past but did not immediately make a purchase.

How much should I pay for insurance leads? This depends on several factors, including the type of insurance and the quality of the leads. It’s important to track your ROI to ensure you’re not overspending on leads.

How do I get insurance leads to come to me? By providing exceptional service, personalizing your communication, and utilizing different communication channels, you can attract more insurance leads.

Remember, aged auto insurance leads can be an invaluable asset to your sales strategy. Armed with these tips, you’re ready to make the most out of every opportunity. Let’s get those leads closed! 

By : Paul Young

Finance Icon

Copyright © 2023 | All Rights Reserved